THE PEOPLE ASK: WHEN WILL THE RULE OF LAW BEGIN TO FUNCTION?
Yesterday in the People’s Assembly
— FROM OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENTS —
Yesterday at 10:00, the People’s Assembly resumed its work after a “break” of 7 days. During this period the deputies became better acquainted with and exchanged constructive views on the new draft Constitution. Several meetings were also held between the parliamentary groups of the PPSH and PD. Discussion of the state’s fundamental document—the Constitution—was placed on the agenda. Until 14:00, the deputies held discussions. The explanation that action should be taken as quickly as possible, but with greater competence and reason, was heard in almost all the discussions by PPSH deputies. In his remarks, PPSH deputy Lufter Xhuveli emphasized the need to unblock the state’s activity. Below, deputy Lufter Xhuveli expressed his view on something else. There is no doubt that the draft presented is one of the highest-quality ones, according to the most advanced standards of European democratic states, he said. Such is, for example, the chapter dealing with human freedoms and rights. Labour Party deputy Leon-[??] Çuçi called for the new draft Constitution to be approved in principle. He argued that this was necessary in order to begin putting it into effect. This does not mean taking hasty steps, something PD deputies Abdi Baleta and Bardhyl Reso, among others, rightly insisted on; but nor do people agree with making a great deal of noise about nothing. The fact that speakers from both parliamentary groups tried to find common ground was positive. Labour Party deputy Xhelil Gjoni voiced his concern that the mechanism of a vote should not be used for fundamental issues. Naturally, the new draft has its limitations and should be discussed, but it is necessary to resolve the question of the head of state, unblock state activity, further develop foreign relations, etc. The announcement with which the afternoon session began at 18:00—that the parliamentary groups had agreed to approve those chapters and articles of the Draft Constitution that would open the way to unblocking state activity—was good news, but also a factor that should help make the subsequent working sessions more productive. From the outset, the PD deputies disagreed with the consensus reached after 14:00 between representatives of the parliamentary groups, and therefore also with the position of their own party’s parliamentary group. As a result, the session was suspended and there was a break until 21:30, while the parliamentary delegations discussed how to reach a consensus on what to do. the chapter dealing with human freedoms and rights. Further progress was to be made toward approving the draft Constitution. We think this action by the PD deputies makes no sense, given that the PPSH deputies accepted the alternative put forward by the PD itself through its parliamentary representative. Meanwhile, it should be stressed that when the Assembly’s work was suspended, a consensus had been reached that after one week the draft Constitution would be approved in principle and, if necessary, the voting mechanism would also be used. Although the PPSH deputies abandoned approval of the draft Constitution in principle and accepted the proposal of the PD parliamentary representative, the PD deputies delayed the continuation of the Assembly’s work by refusing to accept even this consensus. The question is: whom does this serve? The people, who are waiting for the state to begin functioning as soon as possible. The new elections have set us the principal task of placing at the head of the Party organizations people with as much education as possible. We have considerable weaknesses in this respect, but Party organizations at the grassroots are being organized… [unclear] … During the last two months, more than 50 new [organizations?] have been established, mainly from among the intelligentsia. KQÇO”
… the People’s Assembly after a … better acquainted with the new draft Constitution and exchanged constructive views on it. Constitution—was placed on the agenda. By 14:00, when the Assembly’s work was suspended until it resumed at 18:00, around 20 speeches had been made.
Considering the diversity of views expressed by PPSH and PD deputies who took the floor, it must be said that two opinions, or rather two positions, clearly emerged. The first concerns increasing efforts to unblock, as soon as possible, the activity and functioning of the rule-of-law state through the approval of a modern fundamental legal act, and giving it effect; the second, in the name of the need to study and avoid rushing the drafting of the Constitution, postpones this goal indefinitely. For example, PD deputy Vagjel Stamo said in his speech that the People’s Assembly should remain in session for a full year, working on drafting new laws for the rule-of-law state, and that new elections should be held after that! We would not be wrong to express the opinion of many, many citizens in saying that such a thing would cause great harm to Albanian society and the state in the difficult circumstances they are going through. The people rightly expect this Assembly to deliberate with the utmost responsibility and approve the Constitution as soon as possible, elect the President and the new Government, and set the country on the path of development of the rule-of-law state.
It is abundantly clear that today the state faces very great difficulties in functioning, which harms not only economic stabilization but also social stability. Look at what is happening in many cities. The law is being violated left and right, and no one is held accountable. The economy, which has been on the rails of a market economy, requires effective, swift measures and not endless delays, as could happen if the Assembly continues its work for weeks on end…
[The article continues in the following columns:] PPSH deputy Lufter Xhuveli emphasized the need to unblock state activity. Below, deputy Lufter Xhuveli expressed his view on the general discussion of the Draft Constitution and approval in principle of the version presented. The Assembly should commit, he said, to ensuring that every legislative measure undertaken after the Draft Constitution is approved in principle is preceded by discussion and approval of the relevant constitutional article, the article that would open the way to passing laws. He presented another option, which would come from joint meetings, consisting of presenting and approving several key principles that would open the way to the normal functioning of the state, the election of the president and the formation of the government. This deputy urged his colleagues to feel deeply their great civic duty toward the people when discussing the draft Constitution.
The PD deputy who spoke next, Genc Ruli, rejected the request for approval of the draft Constitution in principle and made a proposal that was received with interest by all the deputies and had common ground with the second option proposed by deputy Lufter Xhuveli: in order not to block the work of state bodies, an inter-parliamentary commission should draft a package of laws setting out several essential principles; state activity would begin on the basis of this legislative package, that is, the President and the new Government would be elected.
He also proposed establishing a multiparty commission to draft a new constitution.
In his speech, Labour Party deputy Namik Dokle emphasized the urgent need to begin the functioning of the rule-of-law state. He then focused on the draft Constitution document submitted for discussion and approval and on the progress of the pluralist parliament’s work. He pointed out the Albanian government delegation said that he once again emphasized the importance the Albanian government attaches to these relations and international relations.
Labour Party deputy Leontev in principle. He argued that this was necessary so that measures in the economic sphere could begin to be implemented as soon as possible. He pointed out that the sections dealing with the economy in the draft Constitution open the way to new processes for integrating our economy into the currents of European economic development.
PPSH deputy Fehmi Avdia, in his speech, made clear the … major [change?] in the new draft Constitution, in the section dealing with the separation of powers.
In their speeches, PD deputies Arben Imami and Berlim Çela made many criticisms of the new draft Constitution. Agim Mero did likewise, saying that a package of laws should be approved to clear the way for state activity.
The second morning session began with a speech by PD deputy Pjetër Arbnori.
Labour Party deputy Shkëlqim Cani spoke next. “The economy demands that the procedure be speeded up,” he said. He then explained why: it is at a standstill, in a state of complete crisis. Labour Party deputy Shone Korbeci also discussed these ideas. It is essential that foreign firms be brought in and begin operating. Yet economic ties with foreign countries are somewhat restricted, somewhat blocked. In this sense, we must note that quite a few speakers in yesterday morning’s sessions viewed these issues from the standpoint of “the ruling party should take responsibility.” But in this particular case, the people have no money. …
In the final session, the deputies interrupted their discussion of the Draft Constitution, agreeing with the proposal of three representatives of the parliamentary groups that the report prepared on the events in Shkodër be presented. The deputies requested the information from the Chair of the Parliamentary Committee on Public Order. Nevertheless, deputy Ajli Alushani [raised?] this issue. The deputies’ questions, suggestions and proposals will help ensure that the final report on this matter is presented as soon as possible.
The Assembly will continue its work today at 11:00 and will begin with discussion of the main constitutional provisions.
(Photo: ATSH)